Impact of On-Street Parking Characteristics on Urban Street Level of Service: A Comparison of Two-Way and One-Way Movement Systems
Keywords:
on-street parking, level of service, Highway Capacity Manual, urban street segments, one-way streets, side friction, lane occupancy.Abstract
On-street parking reduces the capacity and speed of urban streets through lane occupancy, parking maneuvers, and side friction, but the size of the effect depends on how parking is configured and used and on whether the street operates two-way or one-way. This paper quantifies and compares these effects for a 1.0 km signalized urban street segment using the urban street segment methodology of the Highway Capacity Manual, 7th Edition (HCM 7). Four geometries are analyzed: two-way streets with two and three through lanes per direction, and the corresponding one-way streets with four and six lanes formed by merging both directions. For each geometry, six demand levels (volume sets A–F) are combined with six parking rates (0–100 %) under three modeling families: a no-parking base; a parking-only model in which parked vehicles occupy through lanes; and an all-assumptions model that adds pedestrian, bus, U-turn, and access-point friction and places parking either in a separate lane (Case 1) or in the existing travel lanes (Case 2). We independently recomputed and reproduced all 456 spreadsheet records. Lane occupancy dominates the results: parking rates of no more than 32.5 % were sufficient to push volume sets C–E beyond capacity (LOS F) in every geometry, whereas a separate parking lane changed LOS by at most one level within the model. The one-way configurations tolerated larger parking rates than their two-way counterparts (critical rate 31.1 % versus 20.0 % for set C with four versus two lanes) because their base volume-to-capacity ratio was about 6 % lower, but they incurred larger modeled friction delay on wide cross-sections. Parking-maneuver delay and field calibration are outside the model, so the findings are screening-level.